I'm going to address some of the common themes that seem to be cropping up in the comments and hatemails that people seem to be dashing off with incredible regularity.
1. "You and your kind are traitors to the US and should be charged with treason"
Hmmm. So by expressing our sincere dismay that our home is being ruined by what we see as bad leadership, we are traitors? Everyone in my group to a person loves their country, or else they wouldn't be bothered to get involved, certainly not in my group.
So, think back to 1999 or so. Clinton has sent US troops into Kosovo, and you don't agree with it. You love your country, but you believe Clinton is leading it in the wrong direction. You express this opinion, and maybe, just maybe, get some folks organized to demonstrate against it.
Is that treasonous? If you believe totally and without doubt that you are helping to right a wrong that is being done to your country, in the face of harsh criticism and public apathy, then I fail to see where the treason lies. Perhaps you are suggesting that it's treasonous to dissent with the President or with the Administration? If so, then I think a civics lesson is in order.
2. "If you're not supporting our President, then you're supporting Osama/Saddam."
Wrong wrong wrong. I hate terrorism. I have no sympathy for men who destroy innocent lives to make a political point, and I am not against war when it is necessary or justified. I did not take issue with us going into Afghanistan as that was directly addressing a threat to our national security.
But the way Bush has behaved ever since then, once it was decided that we would go after Saddam come hell or high water, has hurt our national security in many ways, not the least of which was removing resources from the hunt for bin Laden (who had attacked us) and diverting them to the fight against Saddam (who had not). By re-prioritizing Saddam and making Iraq the central battleground in the War on Terror, Bush removed any moral authority we had post-9/11 and squandered our chance to really hurt terrorism.
Instead, by spreading our forces thin and preemptively attacking Iraq against the wishes of the majority of the world, without a UN mandate, and with no clear plan for what to do with Iraq in the "Phase IV" post-conquest period, Bush has now come full circle and created a giant terrorist recruitment ad: "See? They are imperialist aggressors! Come join the fight! They don't have enough soldiers to cover you all anyway!"
Am I happy the Iraqi people are no longer under Saddam's thumb? Of course, that's not even a question. But you can't celebrate the ends without examining the means - and it is my firm belief that the means that we used to go into Iraq are going to have a longterm and detrimental effect on the national security of the United States of America.
3. "Why didn't you march against terrorism/Osama/Saddam?"
As soon as Queen Elizabeth II extends the offer of a State Visit to Osama or Saddam, I will definitely participate in the protests against them.
Seriously, protesting against terrorism/Osama/Saddam would be like protesting for oxygen; it's a bit obvious and pointless. Aside from some of the dodgier elements around, nobody is really going to come out and demonstrate on behalf of terrorism. If they did then I would waste no time organizing folks to show up and march flying the flag high. Note I said flying, not burning, but I will address that below.
4. "You're helping those who attack our troops in Iraq."
How? Do you think that some guy sitting on the fence in Syria is going to see us protesting against Bush (not America) and that will be the thing that pushes him to run off to join the fight against Iraq? Honestly?
5. "How dare you protest against your own country in a foreign land?"
First of all, a number of people have made this statement, and it indicates a knee-jerk patriotic response. Find me the place on my site where I say we were marching against America. You will be looking a long time. We were marching against Bush.
I live here. I've lived here for four years. Others in the group here make me look like I'm still fresh off the boat. For one reason or another, be it work opportunities, spousal commitments, or in my case that it's a pretty amazing place to be in your late twenties, a lot of us choose to make our homes here. It may or may not be permanent - I would say that a majority of us plan to return to America when the time comes. The desire to come home is a strong one in most people, and I'm no different. We all love our home country.
So to say that we should not protest when we see that bad things are being done to our country just because we are in another country is a totally meritless argument. It wasn't my idea to have Bush come to London, but I sure as hell wasn't going to let him come through without saying my piece. He's bad for our country, and I'll say it to whoever will listen, whether it's here or at home.
6. "Where were you on Thursday when people were burning flags?"
I made it clear from the beginning that I would not tolerate anti-American displays within the group either at meetings or during Thursday's protest. To my pleasure, on Thursday everybody in our group was marching as proud Americans.
The actual marching part of the protest was peaceful, and, aside from the Communist flags which seemed to be poking up with annoying frequency, I was pretty happy with the crowd makeup - peaceful, respectful and not anti-American.
However, once we got into Trafalgar Square it had gotten dark, and word had gotten round that there might be some "elements" coming from mainland Europe intent on causing trouble. That's all I can tell you firsthand, as I did what I could to keep EAB people well removed from the center of things - I for one found the "toppling Bush's statue" stunt slightly distasteful. I ended up leaving by 5:30 or so.
It was only the next day that I saw that some time after we left, when the crowd was dying down and the organizers were closing up shop, that there was a bit of trouble. It started with some bonfires made out of placards, and some scuffles with police, and then the American flag-burning that, as good TV, inevitably made it on to the evening news. I would not have reacted too well if I had seen someone burning a flag in front of me, trust me on that. But take my word that Expats Against Bush were not present by the time that kicked off, nor would we have been involved in any way.
Unfortunately, at the end of the day, you can't control who shows up to these things, and there were over 100,000 people there (or more, depending on which figures you believe). There were bound to be some rotten apples in the barrel.